I n c o r p o r e a l s  C h e a p  S i n c e  2 0 0 2
N A K E D Louisiana O W N E R S H I P 
All Things Legal in Louisiana




 


June 25, 2004


LSC May Decide Extent of Mineral Lessee's Obligation to Restore

Today the Louisiana Supreme Court granted writs in Terrebonne Parish School Board v. Castex Energy, Inc. The Court's eventual decision will likely determine the existence and extent of a mineral lessee's obligation to restore land to its original condition at the end of the lease, when the lease contains no express provision requiring restoration.

Some history: In Corbello v. Iowa Production, the Louisiana Supreme Court held that when a mineral lease obligates the lessee to restore the property, the lessee must do just that, even if the cost of restoration greatly exceeds the value of the property. But Corbello did not address what happens when the lease does not contain an express provision requiring restoration.

The First Circuit's decision in Terrebonne Parish School Board v. Castex Energy, Inc. answered the question left unanswered in Corbello, holding that La. R.S. 31:122 creates an implied obligation to restore the property. But this implied obligation "is limited by a standard of reasonableness which balances the cost of perfect restoration against the value of the use to which the land is being put." Applying this reasonableness standard, the First Circuit affirmed the trial court's order requiring less-than-perfect restoration. At the same time, applying Corbello, the First Circuit held that reasonable restoration could substantially exceed the fair market value of the land. But the First Circuit vacated the trial court's order requiring the lessees to pay the cost of restoration. Instead, because the lessees were willing to actually perform the restoration, the trial court ordered the judgment to be amended to order specific performance of the obligation to restore.

I don't know who applied for writs or what issues were raised in the parties' writ applications. But my guess is that the Supreme Court's eventual decision in this case may answer the following questions:

(1) At the end of a mineral lease, must the mineral lessee restore the property to its pre-lease condition, even though the lease contains no clause explicitly requiring restoration?

(2) If so, is the obligation to restore limited by (a) the value of the land, or (b) the reasonableness standard adopted by the First Circuit?

(3) If the mineral lessee must restore, should the court render a money judgment for the cost of restoration, or should the court instead order specific performance of the obligation to restore?

Posted by RPW at June 25, 2004 06:56 PM
Naked Ownership Resources
Codes and Statutes
News Links
Parish Data

Other Resources
Judicial Interest Rate
Prescription [pdf]
Westlaw
Lexis

Naked Ownership Maps
Judicial Districts
Appeal Courts
Federal Courts
Parish

Court Rules
State District
LA Uniform Appeal
LA First Circuit
LA Second Circuit
LA Third Circuit
LA Fourth Circuit
LA Fifth Circuit
State Supreme
Federal District (La.)
US Bankruptcy (ED)
US Bankruptcy (MD)
US Bankruptcy (WD) [pdf]
US Fifth Circuit
US Supreme

State Court Sites
Supreme
First Circuit
Second Circuit
Third Circuit
Fourth Circuit
Fifth Circuit

Federal Court Sites
Eastern District
Middle District
Western District
Fifth Circuit

Bankruptcy Court Sites
Eastern District
Middle District
Western District

Louisiana Blawgers
AJ Levy
Steve Covell
Bradley Parker
Ernest Svenson
Ray Ward
Gideon's Promise
Kitty Says

BAR ASSOCIATIONS
American
State
Baton Rouge
Lafayette
New Orleans
Shreveport

LAW LIBRARIES
State
LSU
Loyola
Southern
Tulane

LAW SCHOOLS
LSU
Loyola
Southern
Tulane
Home
E-Mail
Syndicate / RSS

About
The Name
Disclaimer
Copyright

Contributors
Al J. Robert, Jr.
Raymond P. Ward
Ernest E. Svenson
You?

Browse by Month:

Browse by Category:

AG Opinions (2)
Alexandria (35)
Attorneys (14)
Baton Rouge (198)
Blawgistan (1)
Blawgs (10)
Civil Law (1)
Community (23)
Dicta (21)
District Courts (4)
Ethics (15)
Federal courts (1)
Judges (18)
LA 1st Circuit (17)
LA 2nd Circuit (10)
LA 3rd Circuit (3)
LA 4th Circuit (4)
LA 5th Circuit (1)
LA Case Opinions (1)
LA Register (1)
LA Supreme Court (46)
Lafayette (49)
Lake Charles (27)
Law Enforcement (2)
Law School (1)
Legislation (37)
Making A Differnce (6)
Meta (4)
Monroe (46)
National (6)
New Orleans (213)
Politics (9)
Practice (16)
Reference (2)
Shreveport (87)
Site of the Day (9)
State (8)
Technology (3)
US 5th Circuit (36)
US District Courts (8)


Site Meter